Should You Expand? A Simple Framework for Business Investment Decisions
How to evaluate growth opportunities without gambling on gut feeling
Opening a new location, launching a new product line, buying equipment, hiring staff - these decisions can make or break a business. Too many owners make them based on excitement rather than analysis. Here's a simple framework to evaluate any business investment opportunity.
Start With Break-Even Analysis
Before any investment, calculate how much additional revenue you need just to cover the new costs. This is your break-even point - the minimum the investment must achieve to not lose money.
- List all new fixed costs (rent, salaries, loan payments)
- Estimate variable costs per sale
- Calculate: Break-even revenue = Fixed Costs / (1 - Variable Cost %)
Apply the Payback Period Test
How long will it take for this investment to pay for itself? The shorter the payback period, the lower the risk. For most SMBs, investments that don't pay back within 2-3 years are risky.
- Calculate expected additional monthly profit
- Divide total investment by monthly profit = payback months
- Add 50% buffer to your estimate - things always take longer than planned
Assess the Risk: What If Things Go Wrong?
Every investment has a downside scenario. Before committing, honestly assess what happens if the investment underperforms.
- Can you survive if revenues are 50% of projections?
- Is this an all-or-nothing bet, or can you scale back if needed?
- What's your exit strategy if it doesn't work?
Check Your Current Financial Health
Expansion should come from a position of strength, not desperation. If your current business isn't financially healthy, adding complexity will usually make things worse.
- Do you have 3-6 months of operating expenses in reserve?
- Is your current operation profitable and stable?
- Can you afford this investment without betting the whole company?
The Gut Check Questions
After the numbers check out, ask yourself these qualitative questions:
- Do you have the management capacity to oversee this expansion?
- Does this align with your long-term vision for the business?
- Are you excited about this, or just feeling pressured to grow?
- What would you advise a friend in your situation to do?
Numbers First, Then Decide
Good business decisions combine analysis with intuition. Do the math first - if the numbers don't work, stop there. If they do work, then factor in your gut feeling and strategic vision. This framework won't give you the answer, but it will ensure you're making an informed decision rather than gambling.
Need Help With Investment Analysis?
We create detailed investment models for new locations, products, and equipment purchases. Book a free consultation to discuss your expansion plans.
Book Free Consultation